Guide
What to do if a car repair goes wrong
Updated . Facts checked against Citizens Advice, legislation.gov.uk and GOV.UK in November 2026, with the sources listed at the end.
In short
- A garage has to do the work with reasonable care and skill. If it didn’t, you can usually ask it to do the work again, or in some cases to cut the price.
- A quoted price is usually binding, an estimate can be exceeded within reason, and with no price agreed the bill has to be reasonable.
- If you need the car back while you dispute the bill, you can pay ‘under protest’ and write those words on the paperwork.
- If you still can’t agree, a trade association or a dispute resolution scheme may help, or you may be able to claim through the courts.
Post the job free with your registration and postcode. Garages on MatchMechanic can see it and choose whether to quote.
Request quotesTalk to the garage, then put it in writing
Citizens Advice’s first step is always to try to sort it out with the garage. Speak to it in person or by phone, explain what’s wrong and say what you’d like it to do. If it won’t agree, write to it or email it, so there’s a record of what you asked for and when.
Before you spend money on a hire car or extra travel, ask the garage what it can do to help, and keep the receipts for anything you do spend. It usually helps to note each conversation too: the date, who you spoke to and what was agreed.
If the repair didn’t work
Ask the garage to put right anything it didn’t repair properly, a fault it didn’t diagnose correctly, or a new problem the work created.
The Consumer Rights Act 2015 says a trader must carry out a service with reasonable care and skill (section 49). If the garage didn’t, you can require it to do the work again, at its own cost, within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience to you (section 55). If that’s impossible, or the garage doesn’t do it that way, you can ask for an appropriate price reduction, which can sometimes be the full price (section 56). A refund owed then has to be paid within 14 days of the garage agreeing to it.
What’s reasonable can be hard to agree, so Citizens Advice suggests a second opinion from another garage, or an independent report on the work that you and the garage agree in advance to accept. If the garage won’t help, you may be able to get money back through your bank with a ‘chargeback’. If you paid by credit card for a repair costing more than £100, Citizens Advice says a section 75 claim may be the easier route.
If the bill is more than you agreed
It depends on what you agreed before the work started:
- A quote is the garage’s promise to do set work for a set price. That price usually stands, even without a signature, though you can ask for it to come down. If you’re charged more than you agreed and think that’s unreasonable, you can take it further.
- An estimate is the garage’s best guess rather than a promise, so the bill can be higher, within reason. If the extra looks too much, ask for a reduction.
- With no price agreed, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 says you must pay a reasonable price, and no more (section 51). Extra time or parts the job needed can make a higher bill reasonable, and another garage’s opinion can help you judge it.
If the garage did work you didn’t ask for
If you told the garage to do whatever the car needed, it could decide the work, and you’ll usually have to pay for work that was necessary, at a reasonable price.
If you agreed only particular work and the garage went further, you can ask it to reverse the extra work, and where that can’t be done, say you’ll pay only for what you agreed to. It usually helps to tell a garage from the start to check with you before doing anything extra.
If it’s taking too long
Ask whether the garage can lend you a courtesy car, though not all garages have one, and keep a record of any extra travel costs. If the car is waiting for bodywork parts, you could ask to keep using it until they arrive.
If the garage has missed a date you agreed, try to agree a new one. Where the contract set no date, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 says the garage must carry out the work within a reasonable time (section 52), and if it doesn’t, you have the right to a price reduction (sections 54 and 56). If you paid in advance, that can mean asking for some of your money back.
If the garage damaged your car
Point out the damage as soon as you see it, or it could look as if you accepted it, and ask the garage to pay to put it right. That usually means the cost of repairing the damage, not always a new part: a scratched door might be resprayed rather than replaced.
Citizens Advice suggests reminding the garage that traders have a ‘responsibility of care’ under the Consumer Rights Act 2015. It also says a notice saying the garage isn’t responsible for damage may be an unfair term, so the garage may still be liable. You may be able to claim on your own insurance instead, though you could lose your no-claims bonus, or ask the garage’s insurer to pay, which it doesn’t have to do.
Getting your car back while you disagree
While you dispute the bill, the garage isn’t allowed to sell the car or get rid of it, but it can keep it, Citizens Advice says.
If you need the car, you can pay in full ‘under protest’ and tell the garage you’ll take the matter further. Write ‘paying under protest’ clearly on the garage’s copy of the repair order and on any receipt: without those words, the garage could argue you accepted the charges. It doesn’t guarantee a refund, but you may still be able to dispute the bill afterwards. If you can’t pay it all, Citizens Advice suggests offering a reasonable amount to collect the car and disputing the rest separately.
If you still can’t agree
When talking hasn’t worked, Citizens Advice’s advice on car repairs suggests these routes:
- A trade association. If the garage belongs to one, such as The Motor Ombudsman or the Retail Motor Industry Federation, it may offer a free conciliation service. It can only help with a garage that’s a member.
- Alternative dispute resolution (ADR). A third party helps you reach an answer without going to court. Ask whether the garage belongs to an ADR scheme, and keep a record of when you asked, in case you end up in court.
- Trading Standards. A garage that quoted one price and charged another, or used misleading or unfair practices, can be reported.
- Another garage. Having the work finished elsewhere is risky: you’d probably need a court claim or a trade association to recover the extra cost, with no guarantee.
For England, the Citizens Advice consumer service can give impartial advice, explain the law and pass a complaint to Trading Standards, but it can’t make the complaint for you or go to court on your behalf. GOV.UK’s list of consumer helplines gives Citizens Advice for England and Wales, Advice Direct Scotland, and Consumerline in Northern Ireland.
A court claim
GOV.UK’s guide to making a court claim for money explains how to claim money you’re owed from a business through a county court, once known as the ‘small claims court’. You may not need a hearing if the garage agrees to pay or you reach an agreement through mediation, which the court may arrange free, depending on the amount. The guide sets out the fees; Advicenow and Citizens Advice give advice on claims; and Scotland and Northern Ireland have a different process.
What MatchMechanic does and doesn’t do
MatchMechanic does no repairs and offers no warranty, so the work and any guarantee on it are between you and the garage. You pay the garage directly, not MatchMechanic.
A garage can change its quote only until one is accepted. The quote you accepted shows its price and anything the garage listed as included, which can help when you and the garage talk about what was agreed. You can rate the garage from My jobs. What happens after you accept a quote is in How it works.
If a garage seems to have broken our terms of use, you can tell us through our contact page. When you next weigh up quotes, our guide to comparing garage quotes sets out what to check.
Sources
- Citizens Advice: Problem with a car repair
- legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, Part 1, Chapter 4 (services)
- Citizens Advice: Contact the consumer service
- GOV.UK: Consumer rights
- GOV.UK: Make a court claim for money
Checked against Citizens Advice, legislation.gov.uk and GOV.UK in November 2026. Rules and figures change, so the pages above have the latest.