Guide
Can an independent garage service my car under warranty?
Updated . Facts checked against the CMA’s guidance on GOV.UK in November 2026, with the sources listed at the end.
In short
- The CMA’s guidance says a carmaker’s warranty that only applies if work it doesn’t cover is done within the maker’s authorised network is likely to be caught by competition law.
- It says one that requires the maker’s own-brand (OEM) parts for replacements it doesn’t cover may be caught too.
- The guidance says the Competition Act’s ban on anti-competitive agreements doesn’t stop a warranty provider legitimately refusing a claim where what led to it is causally linked to work a repairer didn’t do in the correct manner, or to the failure of a part supplied by a third party.
- The guidance generally treats an extended warranty from the maker’s network, sold with the car or shortly after, in the same way. For one sold years later, it says independent repairers seem less likely to be significantly shut out.
Post the job free with your registration and postcode. Garages on MatchMechanic can see it and choose whether to quote.
Post your service jobWhat the CMA’s guidance says about warranties
The CMA published its guidance on motor vehicle agreements on GOV.UK in June 2023. It’s competition-law guidance: GOV.UK says it’s intended to help businesses assess their agreements, so it’s written for businesses such as carmakers and their dealer and repairer networks, not as a list of your rights as a driver. It does show how the CMA looks at warranty terms that limit where a car can be serviced.
The CMA’s guidance says some warranty restrictions may shut independent repairers out, and may close off other ways of making and selling parts, which in the end may affect what drivers pay for repairs and maintenance. It gives two examples that are likely to be caught by the Competition Act 1998’s ban on anti-competitive agreements: restrictions on servicing, and restrictions on parts.
The servicing example is a carmaker’s warranty, standard or extended, that only applies if repairs and maintenance the warranty doesn’t cover are carried out by the maker’s authorised network. The guidance says that in principle it makes no difference whether a restriction like this is in a contract or in a service booklet.
It adds that any other warranty restriction which indirectly limits what it calls the consumer’s right to have repairs and maintenance done by independent repairers, those that aren’t authorised repairers for the make, is likely to fall within the same ban. On the other hand, it says terms from a carmaker or its network that clearly state the consumer’s right to use an independent repairer without losing the benefit of the warranty are unlikely to raise competition concerns.
The maker’s own parts, or parts of matching quality
In the guidance, original parts are the components used to build the car in the first place. They’re made to the carmaker’s specifications and production standards and typically carry its trademark: these are OEM parts. The alternatives include original parts made and sold by the original equipment suppliers (OES parts), and other parts that match the quality of the original ones.
The CMA’s guidance says that warranty conditions requiring parts with the carmaker’s brand for replacements the warranty doesn’t cover may be caught by competition law in the same way as the servicing restriction. It also says it seems doubtful that agreements containing such conditions could benefit consumers in a way that would make them exempt.
What the guidance says about refused warranty claims
The CMA’s guidance also says the Competition Act’s ban on anti-competitive agreements doesn’t stop a carmaker, or any other warranty provider, from legitimately refusing a warranty claim where what led to the claim is causally linked to:
- a repairer failing to carry out a particular repair or maintenance job in the correct manner
- the failure of a spare part supplied by a third party
The guidance doesn’t decide any particular claim: that usually comes down to the warranty’s own terms and what caused the fault. It’s one reason to keep a detailed invoice for every service, showing what was done and which parts were fitted.
Extended warranties
The CMA’s guidance treats some extended warranties much like the standard one. If a servicing or parts restriction is in an extended warranty issued by the carmaker’s network when the car is sold, or shortly afterwards, rather than in the standard warranty, that generally doesn’t change the assessment. Nor does it matter that an extended warranty with such a restriction is arranged through a third party. What decides it, the guidance says, is whether the restriction is within the control of the carmaker or its network, and so whether it’s likely to shut out independent repairers or other ways of selling parts.
Timing can make a difference. The guidance says that years after a car is bought, authorised dealers don’t have the same privileged access to its owner as they do soon after the sale, so other providers of extended warranties, such as chains of independent repairers and insurance firms, are less likely to face significant barriers to offering theirs. In those circumstances, it says, independent repairers seem less likely to be significantly shut out, even if a warranty from a carmaker or its network has servicing or parts restrictions. So for a warranty bought years after the car, it’s worth reading its conditions closely.
Before you book a service under warranty
The guidance can’t tell you what your own warranty says, so before you book it usually helps to:
- Read the warranty’s terms and the service booklet, for what they say about where the car is serviced and which parts are used.
- Follow the maker’s service schedule, usually in the handbook or service book. Garages’ names for a service vary: see interim, full and major services.
- Ask which parts a garage will fit, and whether they’re the maker’s own or another brand’s.
- Ask for an invoice that lists the work and the parts, and keep it with the car’s service history.
Posting a service job for a car under warranty
When you post a service on MatchMechanic, say under ‘Anything else’ that the car is under warranty, and what its schedule asks for at this service. Garages on MatchMechanic can see your job and choose whether to quote. You can message a garage about its quote before you accept it, for example to ask which parts it will fit, or whether it will update the service book.
MatchMechanic doesn’t check whether a garage follows a maker’s schedule, and it doesn’t do the work itself: that’s between you and the garage. There’s more about the job on the Car servicing page. If something goes wrong after a service, see what to do if a car repair goes wrong.
Sources
- GOV.UK: CMA guidance on motor vehicle agreements
- CMA Guidance on Motor Vehicle Agreements (PDF, GOV.UK)
Checked against the CMA’s guidance on GOV.UK in November 2026. Rules and figures change, so the pages above have the latest.